Grading the people who grade the players

PFF grades players. We grade the analysts who tell you which players to draft. Outcome-grounded — an analyst is right if the prospect's NFL career proved them right, not if the league agreed with their board.

Every number below comes from what each analyst's ranked players actually did in the NFL— the same ruler our own model answers to. Letter grades run A (their boards genuinely predicted careers) to C (barely better than a coin flip). Hover anything for the math.

Rows are ranked by overall grade — foresight 55 percent, top-32 hits 30 percent, bust avoidance 15 percent — so a long, strong record outranks a hot streak in any single column.

Showing 0 analysts. Team-blog rows (0 hidden) toggle on above. Window: 2018-2022, the cohort where every prospect has four full NFL seasons — a complete rookie deal — on the books.